Overall contest - As far as contests go, this one seemed fairly well received on our Server. Any time we include gold in a contest, people seem to be generally happy.
Contest Points - To repeat a comment from my last feedback - "It speaks volumes about the condition of the game when the only way to receive fight pit/Coli points are for other players to 'lower their defenses'". Fight Pit and Coliseum need such an overhaul to be relevant without having to lower defenses.
Gold and token points were acceptable.
Characters - I get that this was a "Halloween" themed contest. Witches, spiders, zombies - I get it. However, Zombie and Skeleton king have been left behind ages ago. Outside of pure crab bait, Zombie has not entered a lineup of relevance in months.
Progress Rewards -
The Good = Bazaar Tokens, Stamina packs, Diamonds, Crystal Shrines;
The Bad = Soul Chests;
The bad thing about Soul Chests is that the main hero is usually somewhat useful but, having spent an entire month opening a chest every day, noted that the support heroes are always heroes that I have 5-stars. The additional ore is also not enough to be useful.
The Ugly = Orangle/Purple chests, Enchanting stones, (3) mithril, raid tickets
REPEAT comment: Orange/Purple chests ARE USELESS! They have been USELESS since their inception. 99% of what I receive from these chests are items that I already have in excess of a 1,000 in inventory. If you choose to give these, it should be in multiples of 10 to ensure maybe 1 in 10 players will receive something useful.
New comments - Grind tickets (raid) should just be removed from the game and built in as a feature. Enchanting stones are pointless with the 1,000s of useless scraps we receive weekly from the challenges.
Rank Rewards - Top 10% got decent rewards for their effort. I unfortunately got bounced from the top 10% in the last hour after I went to bed. Tokens, shrines, skins are generally nice. Enchanting stones (as mentioned above) are pointless.